CSI graduation: Pomp and circumstance, boos and
hisses
Author Erica Jong
alienates some with the tone, length of her commencement speech
Staten Island Advance - June 3, 2005
Best-selling author Erica Jong was booed and told to
"Shut up!" and "Go Home!" during her 40-minute speech yesterday at
the College of Staten Island's commencement exercises.
As Ms. Jong, best known for her 1973 novel "Fear of Flying," talked
about everything from truth in advertising to truth in politics and
the shallowness of public relations -- but said precious little
about graduation -- some of the thousands in attendance on the great
lawn at the college's Willowbrook campus stood up and began to
object loudly.
A little less than halfway through her speech, some graduates began
tossing around an inflatable beach volleyball. Some even got up from
their chairs, just yards from her podium, to go chat with friends
and family who were seated behind them.
Ms. Jong, however, was unfazed.
She continued to speak as though everyone were listening
attentively.
"I'm a writer," said the author of eight novels. "I spend days and
nights playing with words, trying to make sense of them. Telling the
truth has never been easy. It's gotten harder."
She complained that getting to the truth is tougher than ever
because "words have been corrupted."
"Advertisers, politicians, celebrities, they all think they have a
good reason to tell us the opposite of what they mean," Ms. Jong
said. "They advertise products like Viagra that could blind you or
hormone pills that could cause breast cancer.
"Politicians speak the opposite of what they mean. They say clear
skies when they mean pollution. They say collateral damage when they
mean killing civilians."
The public, said Ms. Jong, "writes off many lies as PR (public
relations)" and has stopped expecting the truth.
"Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes pledging their love to Oprah when they
really mean PR," Ms. Jong said. "Do we really need wellness when we
have health? News is what they don't issue in press releases."
Ms. Jong's remarks were met with some vehement disapproval.
"She gave a political speech when she was supposed to be doing a pep
talk," said the father of a CSI graduate who declined to give his
name. "Some graduates wanted to throw stuff at her. Whoever heard of
a commencement speaker talking about body bags?"
Dorothy, a 48-year-old mother of a CSI graduate, categorized Ms.
Jong's speech as "all-around bashing.
"It was disgusting, despicable," said the Fort Wadsworth woman, who
would not give her surname. "She called politicians liars, called us
all liars. She trashed America. Mostly, she just wanted to talk. It
was personal spewing. There was nothing about graduation."
In a statement issued through a spokesman yesterday afternoon, Dr.
Marlene Springer, president of CSI, said: "We are delighted to have
had such a noted author at our commencement. Her message, that we
need to look closely at words and (that) their power is important,
I'm sure our audience understands."
Ms. Jong taught literature and freshman English as a professor at
the City University of New York in the 1960s. Her son-in-law,
Matthew Greenfield, is a tenured English professor at CSI.
In a press advisory about graduation issued by the college May 31,
Ms. Springer lauded Ms. Jong for caring "deeply about her
commitments."
"Her presence is sure to be compelling, provocative and
motivational," she said in the advisory.
Ms. Jong encouraged the graduates to take what they have learned in
the classroom and apply it to the world around them, and not to take
words at face value.
"Whoever controls the words is framing the debate," Ms. Jong said.
"You will be able to be framers of the debate rather than the people
sitting there and listening to the conversation. Listen to what is
said and question authority. I want you graduates to get mad when
you're deliberately lied to."
By
Michelle Maskaly
Reprinted here with permission from the
|
|
